Don't Wait for the Feds!
Environmentalists Urge Legislature to
Act Now to Stop Out-of-State Trash
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE — September 12, 2005
Lansing, MI -- As state House Republicans today unveiled proposals for out-of-state waste contingent on action by the U.S. Congress, environmentalists called on the Legislature to take action now that does not depend on federal approvals.
"Michigan should not wait for the feds," said Brad van Guilder of the Ecology Center, a key leader of Don't Trash Michigan. "We need to address the fundamental economics behind Michigan's trash problems -- right now, it's too cheap to dump in Michigan landfills. The Michigan legislature can and should act quickly to pass dumping charge (surcharge) legislation to protect and benefit Michigan communities."
The House Republican proposed legislation would eventually allow Michigan to block Canadian trash once both chambers of Congress pass legislation giving states the authority to block foreign sources of garbage, but would do nothing about the trash from other states which amounted to over 3 million tons last year. The courts previously ruled that only Congress can grant such authority. Congress has been deadlocked over granting such authority for both foreign and domestic trash, but may grant legally precarious authority to block foreign trash. The legislation is precarious because it could be seen as discriminatory toward foreign trash and run afoul of NAFTA.
"What is really needed is a dumping charge that applies universally to all trash," said van Guilder. Michigan currently charges only 21 cents per ton to dump in Michigan landfills. Since it imposed a $7.25 per ton dumping charge in 2002, Pennsylvania -- the nation's top importer of garbage -- has reduced trash imports for three consecutive years, from 12.6 million tons in 2001 to 10.1 million tons in 2004, Waste News reported in August.
Governor Granholm signed legislation in March 2004 that was the first step in dealing with out-of-state trash. Dumping charge legislation has been introduced in the past by both Democrats and Republicans. In September 2003 Senate Republican's endorsed a dumping charge (surcharge) in the final report of The Michigan Beverage Container and Recycling Task Force. Current dumping charge proposals have been introduced by Democrats in both the state House and the state Senate. Environmentalists urge the parties to work together to develop bipartisan dumping charge legislation.
"Funds collected by a dumping charge would go back to Michigan municipalities to provide the resources they need for important programs such as boosting Michigan's poor recycling rate with the added benefit of discouraging out-of-state trash," said van Guilder.
For more information, contact:
Brad van Guilder
Ecology Center
(734) 663-2400 ext 114
Take Action Donate Events About Membership Newsletters Press Publications Links Contact
117 N. Division St., Ann Arbor, MI 48104-1580 USA • phone 734·761·3186 • fax 734·663·2414 •